Poll: Beatles - Sgt. Pepper Final

I can't believe "With A Little Help" is winning!?!??

me too! I thought is was pretty much a no brainer to "A Day in the Life"

I voted for Day in the Life but I am not at all surprised to see With A Little Help in the lead. Which do you find yourself singing more often? The only time I sing Day in the Life is when I comb my hair in the morning. Well I did when I had hair.

But that's really not the only qualification, if it is one at all for most voters. The question in the poll isn't "Which song do you find yourself singing more often?" it's "Which song is better?" And I'm really very surprised so many people fail to recognise A Day In the Life's greatness. It's one of a fairly small group of songs I would describe as perfect - there is simply no need to improve it, or any way to.

how is the song sung by the only member of the group who CAN'T ACTUALLY SING winning this?

Well, I guess since nearly every Beatle album has a Ringo song on it, I guess the Top 16 poll will too.

Well, we have a tie.  As a result, both of these songs will be appearing in the Top 16 tourney, taking away a planned Wild Card slot.